SolvedBIM85625 | Farming losses: operation of five year rule
From HM Revenue & Customs · Business Income Manual
S67, S70 Income Tax Act 2007
The loss incurred in a tax year is caught by the five year rule where a loss computed without regard to capital allowances is incurred in each of the five preceding tax years. The year of commencement is not counted for this purpose so, in the case of a new business which makes losses consistently, the loss of the seventh tax year is the first to be caught.
Example
Betty commenced trading as a farmer on 6 April 2001 and makes up thir accounts annually to 5 April. Their results were as follows:
| Period of account | Trade profit or loss (excluding CA) | Capital allowances |
|---|---|---|
| Year ended 5.4.02 | Loss £1600 | - |
| Year ended 5.4.03 | Loss £500 | - |
| Year ended 5.4.04 | Loss £1250 | - |
| Year ended 5.4.05 | Loss £3040 | £1240 |
| Year ended 5.4.06 | Loss £4030 | £930 |
| Year ended 5.4.07 | Loss £3600 | £1400 |
| Year ended 5.4.08 | Loss £5750 | £1050 |
| Year ended 5.4.09 | Loss £4750 | £850 |
| Year ended 5.4.10 | Loss £5900 | £700 |
| Year ended 5.4.11 | Profit £900 | £1300 |
| Year ended 5.4.12 | Loss £7100 | £1000 |
| Year ended 5.4.13 | Loss £8480 | £880 |
Betty claimed trade loss relief against general income for all available years. Relief was available or restricted as follows:
| Year of assessment | Relief available | Explanation |
|---|---|---|
| 2001-02 | £1600 | Relief is available on the full loss. |
| 2002-03 | £500 | Relief is available on the full loss. |
| 2003-04 | £1250 | Relief is available on the full loss. |
| 2004-05 | £4280 | Relief is available on the full loss. |
| 2005-06 | £4960 | Relief is available on the full loss. |
| 2006-07 | £5000 | Relief is available on the full loss. Although a loss was incurred in each of the five preceding years, 2001-02 is disregarded for the purpose of the five year test as it was the year of commencement. |
| 2007-08 | Nil | A loss was incurred in each of the five preceding years, which do not include the year of commencement. The five year rule applies and trade loss relief against general income is denied |
| 2008-09 | Nil | The five year rule still applies and trade loss relief against general income is denied. |
| 2009-10 | Nil | The five year rule still applies and trade loss relief against general income is denied. |
| 2010-11 | Nil | In this year Betty made a profit before capital allowances but a loss after capital allowances had been claimed. As the trade made a loss in the tax year, and a loss was made in the previous five tax years, Betty remains unable to claim trade loss relief against general income. |
| 2011-12 | £8100 | There is a loss before capital allowances in this year but in the previous tax year Betty made a profit before capital allowances. The run of consecutive losses computed without regard to capital allowances is therefore broken. A new five year period of consecutive losses will need to be built up before the five year rule can bite again. Relief is available on the loss without restriction. |
| 2012-13 | £9360 | Relief is available on the full loss. |