Skip to content
Solved
SearchBrowse
Sign in

Contents

Official guidance
Employment Income Manual

EIM21000 · The benefits code: general

  • EIM21001 · The benefits code: general
  • EIM21002 · The benefits code: what is meant by a “benefit”
  • EIM21003 · The benefits code: what is meant by benefit: motive of employer is irrelevant: Rendell v Went
  • EIM21004 · The benefits code: benefits and fair bargain: Mairs v Haughey: Wilson v Clayton
  • EIM21005 · The benefits code: benefits chargeable under legislation other than the benefits code
  • EIM21006 · The benefits code: cash payments can be benefits: Wicks v Firth
  • EIM21007 · The benefits code: interaction of the benefits code with the taxing of payments and benefits received on termination or change of employment
  • EIM21008 · The benefits code: interaction of the benefits code with the taxing of payments and benefits received on termination or change of employment: continued
  • EIM21010 · The benefits code: when is a benefit provided: Templeton v Jacobs
  • EIM21101 · The benefits code: cash equivalent of benefits
  • EIM21102 · The benefits code: cash equivalent of benefits: the general rule
  • EIM21110 · The benefits code: cash equivalent of benefits: inhouse benefits: marginal additional expense: Pepper v Hart
  • EIM21111 · The benefits code: cash equivalent of benefits: housebenefits: marginal additional expense: examples
  • EIM21119 · Taxable benefits that are not payrolled: time limits for making good
  • EIM21120 · The benefits code: what is meant by "making good"
  • EIM21121 · The benefits code: when must making good take place?
  • EIM21122 · The benefits code: making good by waiver of remuneration
  • EIM21200 · The benefits code: apportionment of the cash equivalent of the benefit
  • EIM21201 · The benefits code: more on apportionment of the cash equivalent of the benefit: Westcott v Bryan
  • EIM21210 · The benefits code: deduction for necessary expenses
  • EIM21220 · The benefits code: who is the person providing a benefit?
  • EIM21230 · The benefits code: valuation of benefits: special rules for certain benefits
  • EIM21240 · The benefits code: benefits and reimbursed expenses exempt from tax
  • EIM21241 · The benefits code: benefits and reimbursed expenses not chargeable to tax: table
  1. The benefits code: general: contents
  2. The benefits code: what is meant by "making good"

EIM21120 | The benefits code: what is meant by "making good"

From HM Revenue & Customs · Employment Income Manual

Section 203(2) ITEPA 2003

"Making good" simply means giving something in return for the benefit. What is being made good is the expense incurred by the employer or other person providing the benefit. It follows that in order to make good that expense the employee will give money, or something that can be measured in money. Usually the employee will "make good":

  • by a direct payment or

  • by deduction from salary or

  • by a suitable debit to the employee's current account in the employer's books and records.

Any of these methods is acceptable.

The giving of services by the employee, or anything that is not measured in money terms is not "making good", see Stones v Hall (60TC737). (This content has been withheld because of exemptions in the Freedom of Information Act 2000)

As regards "making good" by waiver of remuneration see EIM21122.

PreviousNext
PrivacyTerms